The capability approach in development ethics: a democratic framework for setting development agendas

Gutwald, Rebecca (1); Byskov, Morten Fibieger (2); Watene, Krushil (3); Sengupta, Mitu (4); Kosko, Stacy (5) (2018). 'The Capability Approach in Development Ethics: A Democratic Framework for Setting Development Agendas' Paper presented at the annual conference of the HDCA, Buenos Aires, Argentina 2018.

Abstract

The goal of the panel is to dicuss and critically evaluate Morten Fibieger Byskov's new book "The Capability Approach in Development Ethics", which  focuses on the question how we can establish a democratic approach towers development theory and practice.

The book develops a philosophical framework for selecting goals for development purposes. This inclusive and democratic framework integrates a variety of resources including philosophical theory, empirical analysis, stakeholder deliberations, local knowledge, and advice from development experts. The author contends that we must provide good reasons and arguments in order to justify a particular development agenda. That is, we need to ask why we choose certain kinds of development goals over others, why we include certain agents in the selection process and not others, and why we select goals through one method rather than another.  In response to these questions, the author argues that development should aim at expanding people’s capabilities and functionings. Capabilities and functionings—capabilities that have been realized—tell us what people are actually able to do and be with their resources, goods, and formal freedoms. He advances the view that local stakeholders should have more authority in deciding what a development agenda looks like. This claim to local authority in development can be interpreted both as a claim to political authority and expert authority. Finally, the author argues that ad hoc, foundational, procedural, and mixed (multi-stage) methods need to be synthesized in order to select the best capabilities and functionings for development.  The book provides a philosophical and systematic approach to setting development agendas. It is an important contribution to the literature on the capability approach and development ethics, which will appeal to a broad range of scholars within philosophy and development studies.

Plan of the panel:

Morten Fibieger Bykov will present a short introduction into his work, and then the discussants will provide comments and criticism of the book. Since the panelists come from different philosophical and theoretical traditions and different parts of the world, the panel will ensure a diverse perspective which includes indigenuous knowledge, political theory, social ethics and development theory.

The author, Dr. Morten Fibieger Byskov (Warwick University, UK) will be present to introduce the book.

Confirmed discussants are: Dr. Mitu Sengupta (Ryerson University, Canada), Dr. Krushil Watene (University of Massey, New Zealand), Dr. Rebecca Gutwald (University of Munich, Germany);

Dr. Stacy Kosko (University of Maryland, USA) will chair the panel.

scroll to top